However, sports drinks like gatorade contain sugar and electrolytes like sodium and potassium. Pdf the effect of drinking water and isotonic sports. Childrens and adolescents consumption of sports drinks. Before the rise of sports drinks, athletes and the rest of us drank water when we exercised or got sweaty. The physiological effects of gatorade versus diluted fruit juice.
As stated earlier gatorade does have a good amount of calories which is a downside. The juice and gatorade were differentiated by the removal of the water bottle labels from the bottles containing juice. Gatorade, on the other hand, is one of those power beverages that are regarded as sports drinks. Trade sports drinks for water harvard health blog harvard health. Page 1 of 2 free water restriction nutrition clinic box 356057 1959 n. The physiological effects of gatorade versus diluted. These results prove that gatorade is not better for athletes than water.
Gatorade is a sports drink specifically designed for athletes to replace fluids and electrolytes. Top athletes deplete these materials in their body while exercising, and if they lose too much, it could prove. Results indicated that diluted fruit juice rated higher for fullness compared to a popular sports beverage gatorade, or water. Difference between water and gatorade difference between. The granddaddy of sports drinks is gatorade, a beverage created in the 1960s for the university of florida gators football team. Sports drinks are a big part of athletics and big business around the globe, but some debate whether theyre any more hydrating than water.
Together, the power duo absorbs more than 90 percent of the sports drink market. When you crunch the numbers, an equal amount of original gatorade would provide about 150 mg of sodium, compared to a leading brand of coconut water s 24, reports consumerlab. Water remains the most logical way to hydrate if you arent active, but there is a place for both regular and lowcalorie sports drinks. Consuming several cups of gatorade per day can add hundreds of calories to your diet and mitigate the calorieburning effects of your runs. The ingredients that are in gatorade vary slightly with the flavor but the basics include filtered water, sucralose, citric acid, high fructose corn syrup, and brominated vegetable oil. And if youre a hard core athlete, thats exactly what you need. Gatorade is formulated to replenish the lost nutrients, such as carbohydrates, electrolytes and simple sugars. What are the differences between gatorade and vitamin water. Electrolyte water is easy to make making electrolyte water is a costeffective and healthy way to replace fluid and electrolytes when needed. If you find gatorade to be pricey, it also comes in cheaper forms. Water may not provide the carbs and electrolytes than gatorade does, but it also has zero calories. It contains a smaller amount of electrolytes than gatorade, with only 2.
Bodyarmor is the sports drink that could change everything. Pdf the effect of drinking water and isotonic sports drinks in elite. Whether you chose to go with gatorade or water, make sure you keep your players and yourselves hydrated. Lastly, in 2 out of the 9 trials, the athlete felt better after drinking gatorade. If children require water and a few minerals after a game, why not give them a bottle of water and a piece of fruit. An option with 19 calories and 3 grams of sugars per cup is lowcalorie gatorade. Board index archived life, earth, and social sciences.
Water gatorade was developed in 1965 at the university of florida by a team of scientists led by dr. Gatorade and cytomax were developed to help athletes compete at their optimal level during an entire high intensity activity. After exercise that has resulted in body mass loss due to sweat loss, water and sodium should be consumed in a quantity greater than the losses to optimise recovery of water and electrolyte balance shirreffs et al. Water is caloriefree and sugarfree, while each 8ounce cup of gatorade contains 63 calories and grams of sugar. Vitamin water has added vitamins and minerals which vary by flavor.
Smartwater is not considered a sports drink, but rather water with electrolytes added to enhance the flavor. Powerade vs gatorade vs water nutrition facts and sugar. In fact, the original sports drink, gatorade, was developed to help replenish carbohydrates and electrolytes in high intensity athletes at. In many of these situations, it depended on the individuals preference. Two years later, in 1967, the university of florida beat georgia tech. Gatorade comes in a powder formulation that can be mixed into those big 5 gallon coolers which can save you a lot if you were to buy the individual bottles. Gatorade is marketed as a popular thirst quencher made of artificial ingredients but does provide the body with electrolytes. Gatorade posted the same amount of times as powerade, but saw significantly more engagement with the posts pro file picture is an accurate representation of the brand cover photo is clear, attractive, and follows face books rules links to other social chan nels 15. Its the more highintensity workouts that require the extra perks of gatorade. Drinking enough water every day is good for overall health. If you are only doing a lowintensity workout, water is the better choice.
However, what is contained in those calories are ingredients and benefits that cannot be seen while hydrating with water. Consumption of sports drinks by children and adolescents. If you only drank sugar water and kept excercising initially the body would sense low levels. Unlike regular water, gatorade is filled with electrolytes like potassium and sodium that will be used to replace all those natural electrolytes lost in the body after profuse sweating during a tiring physical activity. Sports drinks are increasingly regarded as an essential adjunct for anyone doing exercise, but the evidence for this view is lacking. The purpose of this study was to investigate the physiological effects of water. Once the juice was prepared, the gatorade and juice were poured into the 20 water bottles. Gatorade vs water 2 abstract the point of this paper is to be informed on whether water or gatorade was better for the body while doing physical activities. Gatorade contains water, sugar, and salt among other ingredients, to both hydrate and replace the carbohydrates and electrolytes lost in sweat while exercising. However, the main mineral in sweat is sodium, something sports drinks like gatorade tend to contain far more of than coconut water. During prolonged exercise, athletes generally take in water or sport drinks to help. Gatorade provides advantages over water if you think you need to replenish sodium or if youre working out for a significant period of time, such as 60 minutes or more, particularly in a hot or humid climate.
Moreover, raw coconut water is a storehouse of electrolytes which will not only help you keep your body from getting any cramps but also stay hydrated. The purpose of this study is to investigate the physiological effects of water versus gatorade during prolonged sub maximal treadmill exercise. And while its sales have long more than doubled that of its closest competitor, powerade, the duo has crushed all comers since the dawn of the sports drink. Gatorade is one of the most popular sports drink on the market today. The unseen dangers of sports and energy drinks rucore. Gatorade has electrolytes which are supposed to help with hydration. Everyday exercisers dont necessarily work out with the intensity or duration needed for the carbohydrate and electrolyte benefits of gatorade.
However, gatorade has been criticized for its high sugar content, as well as the effect of this drink on teeth a study published in the journal of contemporary dental practice found that gatorade can be more detrimental to tooth enamel than cocacola. The british medical journal says it started life as a simple mixture of kitchen foodstuffs like water, salt, sugar, and lemon flavoring. Here is an easy lemonlime sports drink recipe to try. Gatorade punished for dissing water in video game cnn. Bottled water and gatorade are major brands fit for human consumption. Tender coconut water contains more important nutrients than mature coconut water. Gatorade reaches the bloodstream of an athlete quicker due to the use of dissolved minerals and carbohydrates in the. Some beverages marketed as sports drinks have other added ingredients like vitamins, minerals, protein and. Hydration is a very important aspect to be considered when it comes to properly maintaining ones health. This handout explains what to expect if you are on free water restriction while you are in the hospital.
The sports drink gatorade is specifically made to replenish fluids. Take resting pulse rate at the carotid artery neck and record on data table. It explains what is in gatorade to help with the performance and what gatorade does versus water. We selected the topic of comparing which gives you more energy, gatorade or water. As the temperatures heat up, many of us find ourselves reaching for a cool drink to stay hydrated. Depending on how long and how intense your workout is will determine whether it would be better for you to drink water or gatorade. The florida gators had gatorade on the sideline, while georgia tech. This is a common question among athletes, and there are many different opinions on the topic. Sweat, body mass and fluid loss now i will be looking the effects of these supplements on athletes sweat loss and fluid. As plain drinking water has zero calories, it can also help with managing body weight and reducing caloric intake when substituted for drinks with calories, like regular soda. Water 0% 0 none 000nono regular cola 11% 26 high fructose corn syrup, caffeinated, carbonated cola sucrose 95 34 0yes yes orange juice 11% 27 sucrose, fructose,glucose 112 7446 no no pedialyte 2. A healthy person can within limits regulate the amount of water and electrolytes in the body depending on the amount lost and the amount eatendrunk. The effect of drinking water and isotonic sports drinks in elite wrestlers article pdf available in anthropologist 2112.
Answers from trusted physicians on gatorade g2 vs water. In fact, theres a reason gatorade is called a sports drink. The findings in our study are important to exercise physiology as it suggests lower physiological stress when consuming water vs. I really like how much research you did for this post, and how many facts you included. Gatorade vs water running head gatorade vs water 1 the. Water and gatorade are two popular fluids consumed when performing. Benefits electrolyte replacement is the biggest benefit that gatorade offers. Coconut water is made naturally in the fruit and contains 94 percent water, fiber, protein, and very low amounts of sugar and fat. Deborah cohen investigates the links between the sports drinks industry and academia that have helped market the science of hydration prehydrate.
615 1449 171 323 210 852 514 1115 855 822 1274 268 208 2 239 1432 121 1539 1200 531 1141 411 28 194 573 53 618 244 1211 1153 1421 1452 813 1352 152 54 813 1418 1371 1257 750 593 1184 844 1476